OCTOBER 31, 2013
Navigators and Assisters
Trained counselors and organizations are helping consumers enroll in health plans through the Affordable Care Act's new insurance Marketplaces.
|What's The Issue?|
The Affordable Care Act became law more than three years ago, but polls find that the majority of Americans still do not understand the law and how it will affect them. A centerpiece of the law--health insurance exchanges, or Marketplaces--are now open to consumers. The Marketplaces, run by either states or the federal government, allow people to shop for insurance, find out whether they qualify for federal subsidies, and enroll in a health plan.
Educating people about the Marketplaces and helping them understand their insurance options will require a massive outreach effort carried out in part by navigators and non-navigator assisters (also called in-person assisters or, more simply, assisters). The troublesome launch of the Marketplaces, in which most people could not shop online, highlights the importance of consumer assistance in getting people enrolled.
People who are frustrated with the online Marketplace can turn to navigators and assisters to walk them through the process. Navigators are individuals or community-based organizations funded by federal or state grants to help guide consumers in the Marketplace, assist with subsidy applications, and enroll in a health plan. Assisters perform many of the same functions as navigators, but they are funded by separate grants or contracts administered by states. A third category of enrollment assisters, certified application counselors, will help people fill out applications and compare health plans but do not receive federal funding through the Marketplaces.
|What's The Background?|
Navigator-like programs are not a new concept and until recently have not been controversial. Probably the best example of a similar program is the State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), which provides one-on-one counseling to Medicare beneficiaries. SHIPs are funded by federal grants and are available in every state.
SHIPs provide unbiased advice on Medicare coverage and benefits as well as private Medicare Advantage, prescription drug, and supplemental plans. SHIPs coordinate with the Social Security Administration; the Administration on Aging; Medicaid programs; and state departments of health, insurance, and aging. In addition to individualized counseling, SHIPs make presentations in the community during open-enrollment periods and throughout the year to explain Medicare. SHIPs played a major role in the rollout of the Medicare prescription drug program, receiving $30 million to help with education and outreach.
The process of comparing health plans, applying for subsidies, and enrolling in a health plan is not always easy, particularly for those who have limited experience buying insurance. Marketplaces are designed to simplify the process by creating a one-stop shopping experience where people can compare health plans on premiums, cost sharing, provider networks, and quality and can find out about available financial assistance.
The Affordable Care Act makes comparability easier by requiring all health plans sold through the Marketplace to cover ten categories of essential health benefits. Many people who come to the online Marketplace may be new to the insurance buying process and may have limited English proficiency. Navigators and assisters are designed to help people who need more assistance than can be offered through a website. In addition to one-on-one help, navigators and assisters can help get the word out on the requirement to buy insurance, the availability of federal subsidies, and how the Marketplace works.
Navigators and assisters can perform the same functions, but there are subtle differences between the two. The Affordable Care Act authorized grant money to assist states to plan and establish their own Marketplaces. A state can use establishment grant money to plan and administer its navigator program, but navigators cannot be paid out of these grants. Navigators must be paid out of the operational budget of the Marketplace, which in most states is funded by an assessment on premiums for health plans sold in the Marketplace. As a result, state Marketplaces will not have a funding stream for navigators until insurance coverage begins in January 2014, potentially making navigators unavailable for the open-enrollment period that began October 1, 2013.
In addition to navigators, the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) created non-navigators, or assisters, who can be funded out of establishment grants. In a state-based exchange, assisters are optional but encouraged, whereas navigators are required. Assisters are required to be distinct from navigators in some way (for example, paid as a contractor instead of through a grant). The federal Marketplace, operated by HHS, has a separate grant mechanism for navigators and will not be using assisters. Assisters will be in partnership Marketplaces in which a state enters into a consumer assistance partnership with HHS.
HHS recently announced the award of $67 million for navigator organizations in states where HHS will be running the Marketplace. This funding is in addition to the $150 million in grants provided to community health centers nationwide to be certified application counselors. This is a relatively small amount of money given the size of the task.
|What's In The Law?|
The Affordable Care Act lists five duties for navigators: (1) perform public education and outreach activities; (2) distribute fair and impartial enrollment information on health plans and the availability of federal subsidies; (3) facilitate enrollment in qualified health plans; (4) provide referrals to appropriate agencies for grievances or complaints; and (5) provide all information in a manner that is linguistically and culturally appropriate for the consumer.
Navigators must have existing relationships or be readily able to establish relationships with likely Marketplace consumers, including the uninsured or underinsured, self-employed people, and small employers. They must complete online training designed or approved by HHS, pass a certification test, and be recertified annually. States can establish their own training and certification requirements in addition to or instead of those created by HHS. Navigators may not receive benefits directly or indirectly from an insurance company, including a stop-loss insurer.
Assisters were not part of the Affordable Care Act but were established by HHS under its regulatory authority. HHS is requiring all assisters to meet the same education, training, and conflict-of-interest standards required for navigators.
Certified application counselors, as the name implies, are people who help consumers with the nuts and bolts of filling out an application and enrolling in a health plan. They are community-based organizations, such as community health centers and hospitals, that have existing relationships with potential applicants. Like navigators, certified application counselors cannot be funded out of Marketplace establishment grants. They will exist in all states and are similar to organizations that have provided application assistance in Medicaid in some states.
|What's The Debate?|
UNEQUAL FUNDING ACROSS STATES: It is safe to say that Congress did not anticipate 34 states' passing on the opportunity to establish their own state-based Marketplaces in favor of one run by the federal government. HHS is now operating a Marketplace in states that account for two-thirds of the uninsured. As a result, the law did not provide adequate funding for a federal navigator program, forcing HHS to be creative in finding alternative resources.
States that operate their own Marketplaces have much more money available for consumer assistance because they can tap into the Marketplace establishment grants. For example, Maryland, which has about 700,000 uninsured residents, is reportedly spending $24 million on consumer assistance compared with $8 million in federal grant money for Texas and its estimated 6.4 million uninsured residents. Together, California and Maryland are spending about the same amount on consumer assistance as all states with federally run Marketplaces combined.
CONFLICTS WITH AGENTS AND BROKERS: Although the navigator program was largely uncontroversial when it was written into the Affordable Care Act, it has proved to be quite contentious. Much of the work navigators do is similar to what health insurance agents and brokers do, except that agents and brokers generally receive a commission from insurance companies for each policy sold.
Agents and brokers, also sometimes called producers, are required to be licensed in every state. As part of the licensing requirement, they might be required to complete training and pass a certification exam, pay a licensing fee, be fingerprinted, or submit to a background check. In addition, some states require agents and brokers to maintain errors and omissions insurance, which is basically insurance intended to protect agents and brokers in case a consumer sues them for poor advice. Although licensed agents and brokers can be navigators, states cannot require navigators to be licensed brokers or agents, and at least one navigator entity must not be.
Agents and brokers have been lobbying state legislatures to pass laws imposing additional requirements on navigators. To date, 17 states have passed navigator laws, and legislation is pending in additional states. Additionally, several states without laws are passing emergency regulations to place additional requirements on navigators and assisters. Most of the states that have passed legislation are states in which HHS is operating the Marketplace, making the additional requirements appear to be politically motivated. Additional requirements have deterred some consumer organizations from participating in the navigator program and could undermine the success of Marketplaces.
In its final regulation on navigators and assisters, HHS says that states may require additional licensing or certification for navigators, but they cannot prevent navigators from fulfilling their duties outlined in the Affordable Care Act. Looking at some of the state laws, it is clear there are going to be questions as to when state laws prohibit navigators from doing their job. For example, the Maine law says that only licensed producers may make recommendations and enroll people in health plans offered through the Marketplace, one of the principal duties of navigators.
PRIVACY SAFEGUARDS AND TRAINING ADEQUACY CONCERNS: In a letter sent to Kathleen Sebelius, secretary of HHS, in August, 13 state attorneys general outlined concerns they have regarding navigators and assisters, including weak privacy protections and inadequate training. Navigators are likely to be privileged to sensitive information, including consumers' Social Security numbers and tax returns, in the process of helping them apply for federal subsidies.
In its letter, the state attorneys general note that the privacy requirements for navigators are not as strict as those for federal census workers or proposed requirements for tax preparers. HHS responded that navigators will receive training on privacy and security standards as part of the certification process and that personally identifiable information is transferred to the federal data hub rather than kept by the navigator. In addition, navigators are subject to civil monetary penalties for privacy violations.
The state attorneys general also raise concern that the training requirements are inadequate given the complexity of the law and health plan choices. Navigators must not only understand and be able to explain how the Marketplace works but how eligibility for federal subsidies is calculated and how the state Medicaid eligibility is determined. HHS requires navigators and assisters to undergo up to 30 hours of training, pass a certification exam, and be recertified annually. Opponents of the law have pointed to recent media reports that HHS lowered the training requirement to 20 hours as crunch time approached to get navigators and assisters certified, but HHS plans to do continued training to make up the difference.
The state attorneys general letter raises a number of detailed questions for the navigator program, including how personnel will be screened and what specific guidance they will be given; what liability navigators will bear if they misuse personal information; what types of fraud prevention and penalties will be available to HHS as it monitors navigators; and finally to what extent states can impose further restrictions and privacy protections on navigators.
CONGRESSIONAL INQUIRIES OF NAVIGATOR PROGRAMS: Recently, members of Congress have begun investigating the navigator and assister programs as well as the organizations that have received federal grants. In June Rep. Darrell Issa (R-CA), chair of the House Oversight Committee, sent a letter to Sebelius accusing HHS of circumventing the Affordable Care Act prohibition on funding navigators through Marketplace establishment grants by creating assisters.
In August, 15 Republican members of the House Energy and Commerce Committee sent detailed requests for documents to organizations that received recent HHS navigator grants. These requests were met with skepticism by the organizations because most have yet to spend any of the grant money, and the time required to gather all the information diverted them from their duties as navigators. As a result of these inquiries, at least four organizations returned federal grant money instead of spending resources to gather information required by Congress.
Navigators and assisters are key components in the success of the Marketplaces. With the rough launch of the Marketplaces making it difficult for people to shop for plans and enroll online, navigators and assisters are more important than ever. Much of the job educating and enrolling people will be on a one-on-one basis, a time-intensive and costly effort that will be more difficult in states that are hostile to the law.
In addition to navigators and assisters, HHS is relying in part on not-for-profit organizations that have pledged to provide outreach and education on the Affordable Care Act. More than 100 organizations have signed on as Champions for Coverage, including the American Hospital Association, Families USA, and Enroll America.
The battle over state laws imposing additional requirements on navigators will likely play out over the next several months as navigators and assisters begin their work. HHS may need to issue clearer guidance on when federal law preempts state laws that may prohibit navigators from fulfilling their duties.
Brooks T, Kendall J, "Countdown to 2014: Designing Navigator Programs to Meet the Needs of Consumers," Georgetown University Health Policy Institute, July 2012.
Center for Consumer Information and Insurance Oversight, Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, "In-Person Assistance in the Health Insurance Marketplace," cited October 25, 2013.
Folkemer D, Spicer L, John J, "Navigators: A Background Paper," Hilltop Institute, University of Maryland, Baltimore County, August 11, 2011.
Jost T, "Implementing Health Reform: The Final Navigator Rule," Health Affairs Blog, July 13, 2013.
Kusnetz N, "Obamacare's Hidden Battle: Insurance Agents Push State Regulation of Guides to New Marketplaces," Center for Public Integrity, August 9, 2013.
Morrissey P, Attorney General, West Virginia, "Letter from State Attorneys General to the Honorable Kathleen Sebelius," August 14, 2013.
Ten Napel S, Eckel D. "Navigators and In-Person Assistors: State Policy and Program Design Considerations," State Health Reform Assistance Network, March 2013.
|About Health Policy Briefs||
Editorial review by
Health Policy Briefs are produced under a partnership of Health Affairs and the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
Cite as: "Health Policy Brief: Navigators and Assisters," Health Affairs, October 31, 2013.
Sign up for free policy briefs at:
- From The Editor-In-Chief
- Entry Point: Overdose Treatments
- Dementia Caregiving Quantified
- Early California ACA Expansion Results
- Universal Health Coverage In Latin America
- Europe's Lessons On Insurance Risk Selection
- Financial Woes For Some Rural Hospitals
- Ambulatory Surgery Payment Rates
- Physician Practice Competition And Prices
- Life Expectancy Disparities Due To Job Traits
- DataWatch: LGB Insurance Coverage Gains
- Narrative Matters: Poetry Meets Health Care
- View Table of Contents »
- Measuring What Matters In Primary Care 06 Oct 2015
- Health Affairs October Issue: ACA Progress, Health And Social Supports 05 Oct 2015
- What State Policies Best Foster Insurance Market Competition? 05 Oct 2015
- Creating The Next Generation: The Payment Model We Need From Medicare 05 Oct 2015
- The Latest Health Wonk Review 02 Oct 2015
Now Playing Noncommunicable Diseases: The Growing BurdenBriefing September 09, 2015
- Milwaukee County General October 05, 2015
- The Donor At The VLA October 05, 2015
- The Xelox Sweater October 05, 2015
- Improving the Quality and Efficiency of Care for Older Adults: Lessons From the Field September 18, 2015
- Noncommunicable Diseases: The Growing Burden September 09, 2015
- Health Spending Projections Through 2024 July 28, 2015
- Medicaid's Evolving Delivery Systems July 08, 2015
- The Interplay Between Health And Social Supports
- An Overdose Antidote Goes Mainstream
- Out-Of-Pocket Prescription Costs Under A Typical Silver Plan Are Twice As High As They Are In The Average Employer Plan
- California's Early ACA Expansion Increased Coverage And Reduced Out-Of-Pocket Spending For The State's Low-Income Population
- Less Physician Practice Competition Is Associated With Higher Prices Paid For Common Procedures
- Living In A Country With A Strong Primary Care System Is Beneficial To People With Chronic Conditions
- The Triple Aim: Care, Health, And Cost
- Vulnerable People, Groups, And Populations: Societal View
- Annual Medical Spending Attributable To Obesity: Payer-And Service-Specific Estimates
- The Role Of Nurse Practitioners In Reinventing Primary Care
- An Integrated Framework For The Prevention And Treatment Of Obesity And Its Related Chronic Diseases
- The Triple Aim: Care, Health, And Cost
- Noncommunicable Diseases: Three Decades Of Global Data Show A Mixture Of Increases And Decreases In Mortality Rates
- Hospital Board And Management Practices Are Strongly Related To Hospital Performance On Clinical Quality Metrics
- Medical Myths: Unprepared For The End Stages Of End-Stage Kidney Disease